Residency in Portugal vs Indonesia
Bali is a magnet for remote workers, and Indonesia has a dedicated KITAS for them. But a temporary stay permit does not turn into a permanent one automatically: KITAP is available to spouses of citizens, investors and holders of certain other KITAS. We compare this with Portuguese residence and permanent residency.

| Remote-worker KITAS (E33G) | income from $60,000 a year, valid 1 year; does not lead to KITAP |
|---|---|
| KITAP | permanent permit for 5 years with renewal; for spouses of citizens, investors and holders of certain other KITAS |
| Retiree KITAS | from age 55, around $1,500 a month, renewable up to 5 years |
| Indonesia Golden Visa | from $350,000 (5 years) for an individual |
| Portugal | D8 from €3,680 a month, PR after 5 years |
| Citizenship | Indonesia — 5 years continuous, dual not allowed; Portugal — 10 years, dual allowed |
Short answer
Indonesia suits living in Bali for a year or two on remote work, or a retiree with income from $1,500 a month. If the goal is a permanent status and a passport with Schengen visa-free access, Portugal is safer: time on the D8 and D7 counts towards PR, while Indonesia’s remote-worker KITAS does not lead to KITAP, and for citizenship you would have to give up your current passport.
KITAS and KITAP: what is what
KITAS is a temporary stay permit, usually for 1–2 years (some up to 5 or 10). It is issued for a specific ground: work, investment, family, retirement, remote work. The new visa is processed online and converted into a KITAS at the border.
KITAP is a permanent stay permit: 5 years with renewal, then an indefinite KITAP with a stamp every 5 years. According to consultants, it can be applied for by:
- a spouse of an Indonesian citizen — after 2 years of marriage;
- holders of investment, work KITAS and Second Home — usually after 2–3 continuous years;
- retirees — after a longer KITAS history;
- E33G holders — no.
The transition to KITAP is not automatic — conditions depend on the ground; check them separately with the immigration service.
Comparison by key parameters
| Parameter | Portugal | Indonesia |
|---|---|---|
| Remote work | D8: from €3,680 a month, residence, leads to PR | E33G: from $60,000 a year, 1 year, does not lead to KITAP |
| Retirement | D7: from €920 a month | E33F: 55+, around $1,500 a month |
| Large capital | Golden Visa: funds from €500,000 | Golden Visa: from $350,000 (5 years) |
| Employment | D1, then residence | work KITAS under a foreign-worker hiring plan (RPTKA) |
| Permanent status | PR after 5 years, CIPLE A2 | KITAP — for some grounds only |
| Citizenship | 10 years, dual allowed | 5 years continuous or 10 with breaks, renounce previous |
Remote work: E33G vs D8
Indonesia. The remote-worker KITAS E33G:
- verified income — from $60,000 a year (about $5,000 a month) from abroad and a balance of around $2,000 over the last 3 months;
- valid for 1 year; renewal is formally possible online, but according to consultants in 2026 you often have to leave and reapply;
- you cannot work for Indonesian companies or earn income in Indonesia;
- family — from December 2025 can apply together with the main applicant;
- government fees for the yearly package — around $315–430; decision — about 5 working days.
Taxes. The E33G itself gives no tax relief. At 183 days in the country over 12 months, or with intent to reside (a KITAS longer than 183 days serves as such proof), you are a tax resident on a 5–35% scale on worldwide income — subject to double-tax treaties.
Portugal. D8 — from €3,680 a month, residence for 2 years with renewal, counts towards PR after 5 years and to citizenship. Tax residency is under the general rules; for qualified professionals the IFICI regime at 20% may apply.
Retirement and Second Home
- E33F (retiree) — from age 55, pension or stable income of about $1,500 a month; for a year, renewable up to 5 years.
- Silver Hair (E33E) — from age 60, a $50,000 deposit in a state bank, for 5 years.
- Second Home — a deposit of about 2 billion rupiah (roughly $130,000) or qualifying property; for 5 or 10 years.
Portugal’s D7 requires a lower income (from €920 a month) and has no age limit; PR after 5 years.
Golden Visa and business
Indonesia’s Golden Visa for an individual — from $350,000 for 5 years, from $700,000 in financial instruments or $1 million in property — for 10 years; for a company founder — from $2.5 million. Plus about $5,000 a month in income from abroad. The investor KITAS is for owners of a company with foreign capital (PT PMA); paid-up capital is usually cited at around 10 billion rupiah.
In Portugal, small business — D2; investment — Golden Visa through funds from €500,000.
Employment
A work KITAS in Indonesia is tied to the employer and its approved foreign-worker hiring plan (RPTKA), issued for a year with renewal. In Portugal — D1 and residence; for specialists — D3 or the EU Blue Card.
Citizenship
In Indonesia, naturalisation is after 5 years of continuous residence or 10 years with breaks, knowledge of Indonesian and the principles of Pancasila. Dual citizenship for adults is not allowed — you would have to renounce your previous passport. In Portugal — 10 years (7 for CPLP and EU); you may keep your passport, and a Portuguese passport gives the right to live in any EU country.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can the E33G be renewed indefinitely?
Formally renewal is provided for, but in practice in 2026 you often have to leave and reapply. This KITAS does not lead to a permanent status.
Does buying a villa in Bali give you residency?
Only through Second Home or the Golden Visa if the thresholds are met.
Which is better for a retiree?
Indonesia — if climate and low costs matter. Portugal — if you need a permanent EU status and income below $1,500 a month.
Related visas & residency guides
Working remotely and thinking about a long move?
Our partners will verify your income for the D8 visa and explain how to reach PR and citizenship in Portugal.
Get a consultation →