Citizenship of Portugal, Spain, Italy and Germany: comparison of deadlines 2026
After the reforms of 2024–2026, the rules of naturalization in leading European countries have changed dramatically. Objective legal comparison of Portugal, Spain, Italy and Germany.
| Countries analyzed | Portugal, Spain, Italy, Germany (versions of laws 2026) |
|---|---|
| Time limits for naturalization | From 5 years (Germany) to 10 years (Portugal, Spain, Italy) |
| Language threshold | A2 (Portugal, Spain), B1 (Italy, Germany) |
| Dual citizenship | Authorized in Portugal, Italy and Germany (from 2024); limited in Spain |
Short answer: Selecting a country for third-country nationals (including citizens of the Russian Federation, Belarus and Kazakhstan) to obtain a European Union passport in 2026 requires an in-depth comparison of five legal parameters: residence qualification, language threshold, admissibility of second citizenship, integration testing requirements and rules for family members. If Germany radically liberalized the law in 2024 (lowering the period to 5 years and allowing multiple citizenship), Portugal in May 2026, with the law Lei Orgânica n.º 1/2026 increased the naturalization period for citizens of countries outside the EU and CPLP from 5 to 10 years. However, Portugal still retains the most accessible language threshold (A2 vs. B1 in Germany and Italy) and unconditional recognition of multiple citizenship, while Spain formally requires a waiver of the first passport for most foreigners. [S01], [S02], [S32], [S41]
Summary comparative table of naturalization in EU countries (2026)
| Evaluation criterion | Portugal (Lei 37/81 + LO 1/2026) | Spain (Código Civil) | Italy (Legge 91/1992) | Germany (StARegG 2024) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Duration of residence under residence permit | 10 years (7 years for EU/CPLP; 5 years for cases before 05/19/2026) | 10 years (2 years for Iberoamerican citizens) | 10 years for non-EU citizens (4 years for EU citizens) | 5 years (3 years with special integration success C1) |
| Language level | A2 (CIPLE A2 or PLA course 150 hours) | DELE A2 (Instituto Cervantes) | B1 (CILS/CELI/PLIDA) | B1 (Zertifikat Deutsch / telc) |
| Culture/Values Test | Mandatory under 2026 reform (values test) | CCSE Exam (Constitution and Culture) | Integration interview | Einbürgerungstest (33 questions) |
| Second citizenship | Fully allowed without restrictions | Formal refusal (exceptions for Iberoamerica) | Fully allowed | Fully allowed (June 2024 reform) |
| Physical location | Flexible windows (10 out of 12 years; ARI 7-14 days) | Strict continuous stay (≥ 183 days/year) | Permanent continuous registration (residenza) | Life Interest Center, Continuous Residence |
| Citizenship by marriage | 3 years of marriage (or union União de Facto) | 1 year of legal marriage | 2 years residence in Italy (3 years abroad) | 3 years of residence (including 2 years of marriage) |
| Deadline for reviewing dossier | 24-36 months (IRN delays) | 12–24 months (electronic registry) | 24–36 months (prefectures) | 12–18 months (local departments) |
Analysis of key forks: what is important for the applicant to know
Each European destination has its fundamental advantages and hidden barriers, which general advertising is silent about:
- Portugal: key advantage is tolerance of absence (window mechanism for summing up 10 years of experience within 12 years, as well as a soft regime for Golden Visa investors), low language threshold (A2) and full recognition of multiple citizenship. The main disadvantage is the increase in the term to 10 years and administrative delays at the IRN conservatories.
- Germany: the shortest naturalization period in the EU (5 years instead of the previous 8, and with excellent C1 German - only 3 years) and legalization of multiple citizenship from June 2024. Cons: high language threshold (B1/C1), strict requirements for complete financial independence without benefits, complex income tax.
- Spain: short term (2 years) valid exclusively for citizens of Latin America, the Philippines, Andorra and Portugal. For citizens of the Russian Federation, Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan, there is a general 10-year qualification with a mandatory requirement to renounce previous citizenship upon acquiring Spanish citizenship.
- Italy: The 10-year residence period for third-country nationals requires continuous registration of residence (residenza anagrafica) and proof of stable income at the level of tax returns for the last three years preceding submission, as well as language level B1.
Routes by origin (repatriation): comparison
If naturalization by residence everywhere requires from 5 to 10 years, then the programs for restoring citizenship by roots are radically different:
- Portugal:unique path for grandchildren under Article 1(1)(d) - grants citizenship by birth (atribuição) without the need to reside in the country, only A2 language required. The new path for great-grandchildren (Article 6(8)) requires a 5-year residence permit.
- Italy: The Jure Sanguinis procedure is theoretically unlimited by the number of generations (if the Italian ancestor did not lose citizenship before the birth of the next generation), but in recent years consular queues have stretched for 5-8 years, forcing applicants to apply to Italian courts.
- Spain: The Law on Democratic Memory (Ley de Memoria Democrática), which gave the right to a passport to the grandchildren of Spaniards, was temporary and ended accepting new applications by the end of 2025.
What to read next
- Reform of the Portuguese Citizenship Law: terms of 7 and 10 years
- Dual citizenship in Portugal and other European countries
- Portuguese citizenship for grandchildren without moving: art. 1(1)(d)
- Comparative analytical guides on relocation
- How to live in other EU countries after receiving a passport
Official Legal Sources and Regulatory Framework
Sources and statutory conditions verified against official government publications as of November 1, 2026. For personal filing, always verify the active administrative requirements of your specific procedure.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which European country now has the shortest period of time before a passport for naturalization?
Among the largest countries in Western Europe, the shortest naturalization period is set in Germany - 5 years of legal residence (and 3 years with knowledge of the C1 language and special success). In Portugal, Spain and Italy, for third-country nationals the period is 10 years.
Does Portugal require you to renounce citizenship of the Russian Federation or Ukraine?
No. Portugal fully recognizes multiple citizenship. Portuguese law does not impose any requirements to renounce previous citizenship.
Is it true that in Spain they require you to give up your first passport?
Yes. When naturalizing in Spain, citizens of countries that do not have bilateral treaties (including the Russian Federation and Belarus) take an oath formally renouncing their previous citizenship.
Which language level is more difficult: Portuguese A2 or German B1?
Level A2 is the basic pre-threshold level of survival (understanding of simple phrases and everyday dialogues). German level B1 requires confident grammar, independent conversation and extensive writing.
Related residency & nationality guides
Need legal guidance on your Portuguese citizenship application?
Our licensed Portuguese immigration law partners audit continuous residency, review AIMA and IRN documentation, and manage nationality filings end-to-end.
Get a personal analysis of European routes → →